Eating the right amount of good carbs vs. bad carbs is the key to optimal health and reaching and maintaining your ideal weight.
If you're wondering how to distinguish between good carbs vs. bad carbs, you’re not alone!
It’s often confusing to figure out the difference between the two, and how many grams of carbs is the right amount.
Knowing more about good carbs vs. bad carbs is the key to maintaining optimal health and the slim figure of your dreams.
What are Good Carbs vs. Bad Carbs?
Good carbs and bad carbs are both types of carbohydrates that give you energy and help your body sustain its many functions.
Some key points pertaining to good and bad carbs include:
Good carbohydrates are found in healthy foods that are rich fiber, protein, vitamins, or minerals in addition to total carbohydrates.
Good carbohydrates don’t usually cause giant spikes in blood sugar with corresponding blood sugar drops.
Instead, they help stabilize blood sugar, keeping you energized for longer time periods, and helping you achieve or maintain a healthy weight.
Examples of good carbohydrates that contain natural sugars or starches include:
- Non-starchy vegetables
- Starchy vegetables
- Whole grains
- Low-fat milk
These foods are whole foods, meaning they undergo minimal or no processing. Many are rich in fiber or protein, which both keep you full for longer time periods.
Studies show that increasing fiber helps you lose weight if you’re overweight or obese. It isn't fully digested or absorbed by your body.
So, while fiber fills you up, your body excretes much of it.
Bad carbs are low in essential nutrients, high in calories, or highly processed.
Many of these carbs can make your blood sugar spike temporarily with a subsequent drop in blood sugar and feelings of fatigue.
Bad carbs aren’t usually as satiating as good carbs because they're lower in fiber and may contain added sugar.
Examples of bad carbs to steer clear of whenever possible include:
- Added sugar
- Ice cream, chocolate, and candy
- Doughnuts and other sweets
- Soda, sweet tea, and other sugary drinks
- White bread, white rice, and white hamburger buns or rolls
- Baked goods
- Other refined grains
- Sugary cereals
- Potato chips
- French fries
- Yogurt with added sugar
- Other foods containing added sugar
Foods that often contain added sugar or are naturally rich in sugar include jams, jellies, tomato sauce, other tomato products, syrup, molasses, and honey.
What are Simple vs. Complex Carbs?
You might have heard about simple carbs vs. complex carbs and wonder what the difference really is between the two.
Complex carbohydrates are structurally different and take longer to digest.
Many complex carbohydrates are on the “good carbohydrates” list, but not all.
Starches are examples of complex carbohydrates. Examples of healthy complex carbs include:
- Sweet potatoes
- White potatoes
- Green peas, black-eyed peas, and chickpeas
- Navy beans, pinto beans, black beans, and other dried beans
- Lentils and other legumes
- Quinoa, brown rice, wild rice, oatmeal, and whole-grain bread
- Other types of whole grains
Many of the foods on the good carbs list are complex carbs (but not all). Steer clear of refined complex carbs like white bread and white rice when possible.
Simple carbohydrates break down faster than complex carbohydrates, so you should feel a quicker burst of energy after eating them.
However, the energy you gain from simple carbs isn’t usually as long-lasting as energy sustained from complex carbohydrates.
Healthy simple carbs to consider include vegetables, fruits, and natural sugars in milk.
Unhealthy simple carbs include sugary drinks, sweet treats, and added sugar.
How Many Carbohydrates Should I Eat?
While counting carbs isn’t necessary, it’s often helpful to learn about carbohydrate guidelines and how to fill each meal plate with nutritious carb-rich foods.
Here are some general adult guidelines for carbohydrate consumption:
- Carbohydrate recommended dietary allowance (RDA): 130 grams per day
- Institute of Medicine's macronutrient distribution range: 45-65% of total calories from carbs
- Low-carb diets: about 20-130 grams daily
Studies show that low-carb diets are often more effective than other types of diets for rapid weight loss during the first 6-12 months of dieting.
The National Center for Biotechnology Information (NCBI) defines low-carbohydrate diets as:
- Very low-carb: 20-50 grams daily
- Low-carb: less than 130 grams daily
- Moderate carb: 26-44% of your total calories from carbohydrates
- High-carb: 45% (or greater) of your calories from carbohydrates
The best way to reduce your current carbohydrate intake for weight loss or weight maintenance is to cut bad carbs out of your diet and focus on nutritious, lower-carb foods.
What Are Some Low-Carb Foods?
When choosing low-carb foods for weight loss, consider adding the following to your meal plan:
Many high-protein foods are low in carbs or even carbohydrate-free. Examples of healthy protein-rich options include:
- Chicken, turkey, and duck
- Venison or lean organic beef
- Shrimp, scallops, and other types of seafood
- Low-fat cottage cheese
- Plain Greek yogurt
- Reduced-fat cheese
- Protein powder (without added sugar)
When planning healthy meals, aim to fill at least 1/4th of your plate with nutritious protein foods and consume 2-3 servings of dairy foods (or plant-based equivalents) daily.
When following a low-carb diet, choose plain Greek yogurt, low-fat cottage cheese, reduced-fat cheese, or whey or casein powder instead of milk.
Non-starchy veggies are low in carbohydrates, often containing just 5 grams of carbohydrates or less in each 1-cup portion. Examples of such vegetables include:
- Spinach, kale, Swiss chard, and other leafy greens
- Broccoli, green beans, asparagus, and other green vegetables
- Cucumbers, tomatoes, and bell peppers
- Mushrooms, onions, carrots, and celery
- Baby corn, cauliflower, and okra
Non-starchy vegetables are low in calories too, making them an excellent choice when weight loss or healthy weight management is your goal.
Aim to fill about 1/2 of each plate with non-starchy vegetables during mealtime.
Foods rich in nutritious, heart-healthy fats are satiating and low in carbohydrates.
Ketogenic diets, which studies show can be effective for weight loss, mainly consist of these and other fats:
- Olive oil
- Walnut oil
- Pumpkin seed oil
- Other plant-based oils
- Fish oil
- Nut butter
- Nuts and seeds
Avocados, olives, nut butter, nuts, and seeds do contain carbohydrates, but they're much lower in carbohydrates than fruits, starchy vegetables, and whole grains.
Good Carbs vs. Bad Carbs: Common Myths
You've probably heard contradicting information when it comes to carbohydrate advice, as there are quite a few myths surrounding good carbs vs. bad carbs and how to eat them.
Examples of common carbohydrates myths include:
Myth #1: All Simple Carbs are Bad for You
As discussed above, not all simple carbohydrates are classified as bad carbs because fruits, many types of vegetables, and milk all contain natural (simple) sugar plus vitamins, minerals, fiber or protein, and other essential nutrients.
If you’re confused about the difference between good vs. bad simple carbs, remember that whole foods are good carbs and added sugar and refined foods aren’t as healthy for you.
Myth #2: Carbs are Bad for Weight Loss
It's true that reducing your overall carbohydrate intake, especially calories from bad carbs, is often effective for weight loss.
But your body still requires some carbohydrates to function properly and give you energy, especially during workouts.
Choose good carbs vs. bad carbs whenever possible and focus on protein foods and vegetables when weight loss is your goal.
Eliminate sweets, sugary drinks, and refined grains like white bread.
Myth #3: All Sugar is Bad for You
Not all sugar is bad for you, which is important to keep in mind when reading nutritional labels.
Added sugar is what you want to avoid, which should be clearly listed on the label.
Natural sugars found in fiber-rich fruits, vegetables, and low-fat milk give you energy and help you meet daily carbohydrate goals without the risk of unwanted weight gain.
Myth #4: You Shouldn't Eat Any Bread
It's best to steer clear of white bread in favor of fiber-rich, whole-grain bread whenever possible.
But you don't have to avoid bread altogether to stay healthy and maintain a healthy weight!
Simply cut back on bread or opt for whole-grain varieties to help you look and feel your best.
Consider canned light tuna with avocado slices on whole-grain bread for lunch or a veggie and egg omelet with whole-grain toast for breakfast.
Myth #5: Carbs are Essential for Proper Brain Function
Glucose, a type of sugar, is often your brain's preferred fuel source.
However, if you're reducing carbohydrates for weight loss or healthy weight management, doing so doesn't necessarily affect brain function because your brain can use ketones as a fuel source.
Ketones result from your body breaking down dietary or stored fat.
So while minimum carbohydrate recommendations are set in place as a guideline, low-carb, high-fat diets (ketogenic diets) are also popular and may provide cognitive benefits.
Myth #6 All Carbohydrates Contain Gluten
Gluten, a protein found in wheat and wheat products, rye, barley, and triticale, can cause gastrointestinal problems in people who are sensitive to it.
However, not all high-carb foods contain gluten, including fruits, vegetables, and milk.
Quinoa and rice are usually safe options too but check the ingredient label on breads, cereals, and pastas to know if these products contain gluten.
When processing gluten-free grains in the same facility as gluten-containing products, cross-contamination can occur.
Myth #7 Eating Too Many Carbohydrates Causes Diabetes
If you overindulge in carbohydrates and become overweight or obese, your risk of diabetes increases. So does being physically inactive.
However, carbohydrates don't cause diabetes.
If you already have the condition, it's important to control carbohydrates and eat smaller portions of carbs spaced evenly throughout the day or as directed by your doctor or dietitian.
Eating too many carbohydrates at once can negatively affect your blood sugar.
Myth #8 Total Grams of Carbs is Most Important
Carbohydrates aren't all created equal for numerous reasons, even if they provide the same number of grams of carbs per serving.
Your body doesn't fully digest or absorb fiber, which is why some people subtract fiber grams from total carbohydrates to determine net carbs.
The way carb-rich foods affect your blood sugar, keep you full, and contribute to your overall calorie intake is most important for weight management and your overall health.
If high-carb foods contain fat in addition to carbohydrates, their calorie content increases.
Weight Loss with Good Carbs vs Bad Carbs
When planning healthy meals for you and your family, it's important to keep a few things in mind. Consider the following healthy eating strategies to achieve or maintain a healthy weight in addition to choosing good carbs vs. bad carbs.
- Fill 1/2 of your plate with non-starchy vegetables, 1/4 of your plate with protein foods, and 1/4 of your plate with fiber-rich starches.
- Avoid shopping for and keeping bad carbs in the house.
- Drink a lot of water throughout the day and before meals. Women should aim for at least 12 cups of total fluids daily.
- Pair fiber-rich starches with protein and fat at mealtime.
- Reduce your overall carbohydrate and calorie intake for weight loss. Burn 500-1,000 more calories than you eat daily to drop about 1-2 pounds per week.
- Weigh yourself daily and track your progress over time.
- Get at least 7 hours of sleep each night in a cool dark room.
- Maintain a good social support network. Recruit friends or family members to stay active with you.
- Keep your body moving all throughout the day in addition to getting regular exercise.
- Join an organized weight loss program for women with proven success.
The Fit Mother Project is a healthy eating and exercise program specifically designed for busy women of all ages.
It's beneficial for weight loss, fat loss, and healthy weight management.
When you join the Fit Mother Project program (FM30X), health experts offer you motivational support, custom meal plans, fat-burning workouts, and more to help you reach and maintain your goal weight for life
Start today with the free Fit Mom Jumpstart!
Choosing good vs. bad carbs and making healthy dietary changes has never been easier!
*Please know that weight loss results & health changes/improvements vary from individual to individual; you may not achieve similar results. Always consult with your doctor before making health decisions. This is not medical advice – simply very well-researched info on good carbs vs. bad carbs.